Current International Monetary System


1. European Monetary System

 

Following the collapse of the Bretton woods system on August 15, 1971, the EEC countries agreed to maintain stable exchange rates by preventing exchange fluctuations of more than 2.25%. This arrangement was called "European snake in the tunnel" because the community currencies floated as a group against outside currencies such as the dollar.

By 1978, the snake turned into a worm (with only German mark, Belgian franc, Dutch guilder, Danish krone). However, a new effort to achieve monetary cooperation was launched. By March 1979, EC established European Monetary System, and created the European Currency Unit (ECU).

European Monetary System, 1979 Prevent movements above 2.25 % around parity in bilateral exchange rates with other member countries.
ECU

The European Monetary Cooperation Fund, now part of European Central Bank, allocates ECUs to members' central banks in exchange for gold and dollar deposits. 20% of the quota must be paid in gold (and 80% in USD). ECU was an artificial currency and used in all intrasystem balance of payments settlements. ECU was replaced by euro (at 1:1) on January 1, 1999.

provision of credit facilities for compensatory financing.

 

Then the EMS created the European Central bank (June 1998) and a single European currency (euro 2002).

Since its inauguratation in 2002, euro has gained ascendancy, but sovereign debts of PIIGS (Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain) nations weaken the euro.

   

       
2. Recommended Foreign Exchange Practices (Choi)

(for the benefit of all countries)

small countries

As a general rule, small countries (whose trade shares are less than 1% of world trade) should peg their currency to a major currency or a basket of major currencies. But there is little harm in floating their currencies. The peg should be set at a level to ensure balanced trade. (Remember Greece's debt crisis)

Developing countries There are some developing countries that rely heavily on exports of a few primary products. Also, countries that mostly trade with one country. In this case, pegging to a major currency is acceptable.
large/medium countries

Countries whose trade shares exceed 1- 2 % of world trade (27 countries) should adopt floating rates to insulate their economies from excessive foreign shocks. If trade share exceeds 5% of world trade, the country should definitely float its currency.

For example, China's export share is about 12%, and it should float yuan to protect consumer welfare. (As the reserve asset increases, its real value in terms of yuan or imported goods declines.)

In the foreseeable future (by the next decade, if not sooner), four major currencies (USD, euro, yen and yuan) will float their currencies. India and Russia may follow suit eventually. Large countries may not only hurt themselves (profit from currency intervention will be negative) but also disrupt world trade when their currencies are pegged to another currency to gain a large trade surplus.

Reserve Limit

Foreign exchange reserve should be less than half of export volume. At most, it should not be more than the annual export volume.

Japan: pop = 127 million, GDP = $4.6 trillion,
share in global exports = 3.6%, $683 billion.
Foreign exchange reserve = $1,233 billion.

Japan's foreign exchange reserve exceeds this limit.

China: pop = 1.36 billion, GDP = $10.4 trillion (2014),
share in global exports =
12.3%, $2,342 billion.
China's foreign exchange reserve = $3,526 billion. (down)

US: pop = 319 million, GDP = $17.4 trillion (2014)
share in global exports = 8.5%, $1,620 billion.
US foreign exchange reserve = $119 billion (less than 10% of exports).

Euro area:$340 billion in 2014.

Prolonged undervaluation of one's currency necessarily results in an ever-increasing reserve of overvalued currencies, and inescapable loss from currency intervention.

Current system Currencies of other industrial countries are floating with respect to the dollar. Accordingly, the current system is a mixture of exchange rate arrangements.
 Export volume China = $2.34 trillion, EU = 2.25 trillion, US trade = $1.6 trillion in 2014.

 

3. Current Foreign Exchange Practices

 Europe

Euro area includes most of the European countries, except Swiss Franc and British pound.

 

Swiss Franc, Canadian dollar, British pound, the Japanese yen and the U.S. dollar are floating.

 

The remaining currencies of LDCs are pegged to major currencies or baskets. 

 Asia (dollar invoicing)

Imports of East Asian countries are often invoiced in dollars. For example, about 70% of Japan's imports are invoiced in dollars. This dollar invoicing practically expands the dollar area to include Japan and other East Asian countries (Ronald McKinnon).

2002
 dollar peg is declining

 As of 2008, 17 currencies of small countries are pegged to USD.

In addition to the euro zone of 15 countries, 23 currencies are pegged to euro.

 

As of 2007, 111 countries adopted fixed exchange rates. Specifically, 41 countries have no separate legal tender, 7 countries have currency boards, 52 countries have fixed pegs, 6 horizontal bands, and 5 crawing pegs.

 76 countries adopted floating. (source: IMF)

 

4. Managed Float

 intervention has not declined

 The current system is a managed float, rather than pure or clean float.

Since 1973, the amount of intervention by national monetary authorities has not declined.

The largest holders of international reserve assets are (2016):

China = $3.2 trillion,
Japan = $1.25
Europe = $0.75 trillion
Switzerland = $0.6 trillion

Saudi Arabia = $0.6 trillion
Russia = $0.39 trillion).

 Reasons (i) The response of imports and exports is not spontaneous, but occurs only after a lag (which can take up to a year or more). During the period of adjustment, some surpluses and deficits appear in the balance of payments, which must be financed by the monetary authorities.

(ii) Wide fluctuations of exchange rates may have undesirable effects on inflation, employment and international competitiveness. Thus, central banks may go beyond smoothing daily and weekly fluctuations and maintain the exchange rates at target levels. (this is acceptable.) In this sense, the managed float resembles adjustable peg system.

(iii) In recent years, large countries (e.g., Japan and China) continue to hold large amounts of foreign exchange reserve, instead of smoothing exchange rate fluctuations. (Profits from such currency intervention are negative)

   

5. Jamaica Accord

  Beginning 1972, US and European countries negotiated on the reform of the international monetary system. After four years, an agreement on an amendment of the Articles was reached in Jamaica in January 1976.

A new Article IV of Agreement was approved by the Board of Governors in April 1976, and was ratified by 2/3 of the member nations in 1978. 

  second amendment (copy), 1978

the first amendment permitted creation of SDR.

The contents are:

(i) legitimizing floating rates. A member country is free to choose its own exchange rate system.

freely floating, managed float, pegged to a currency or a group of currencies or SDR. Not to gold.

(ii) The Fund will exercise surveillance over the exchange rate policies, and adopt specific principles to guide member countries.

(iii) By an 85% supermajority, the Fund may reintroduce a system of adjustable peg. However, a member may remain without a par value. (US can veto).

(iv) downgrade the monetary role of gold (gold cannot be used for international transactions).

(v) designate SDR as the principal reserve asset in the international monetary system.

Is it a good idea to Invest in Gold?

onlygold.com

No. Gold price rose from $184 in 1974 to $1200 in 2014. (6-fold increase in 40 years. (growth rate is about 4.5% per year)

DJ index rose from 3000 in 1974 to 17800 in 2014 (6-fold increase in 40 years or, 4.5% per year). However, gold earns no interest while stocks earn dividends (2.7% per year). Thus, net growth is 4.5% + 2.7% = 7.2%. While there might be temporary gains, gold is NOT a good long-term investment.

 

   

6. Principles adopted in 1977

 Three principles   (i) A member shall avoid manipulating exchange rates to prevent balance of payments adjustments or to gain unfair advantage over other countries. (e.g., do not devalue to maintain a large surplus)
   (ii) a member should intervene in the exchange markets if necessary to counter disorderly conditions.
  (iii) A member should take into account the interests of other member countries, including the countries whose currencies they use to intervene.
 Problem  IMF has little displinary power
   

7. Evaluation (Choi)

 Merits (i) Managed floats have not reduced international trade and investment or caused a disintegration of international capital market.
  (ii) have not resulted in quick adjustment in trade flows (deficits/surpluses persisted)
  (iii) Pivotal role of $ has diminished (as prime reserve asset ⇒ SDR). Whether euro will play a major role remains to be seen. Due to China's pegging of yuan to USD, euro has steadily appreciated. This trend will continue until China stops its pegging to USD.
Weaknesses 

(i) exchange rates have been volatile. Increasingly, there are economists who claim that there is overmuch instability.

(ii) IMF does not have any power to discipline members that violate the rules, but the loss from currency undervaluation is a built-in penalty. All it can do is to reject loan requests of such countries which are leastly likely to ask for loans. There is no mechanism to settle disputes.

(iii) IMF's asset is puny. Also, international reserve assets of some countries far exceed the assets of the IMF (SDR 477 billion = $669 billion). PBOC's asset is much greater.

(iv) Major industrial countries use SDR, but not small countries.

   

 

8. New Problems

  Only currencies of small countries should be pegged to major currencies such as dollar or a basket of currencies, but the currencies of major currencies should float vis-á-vis dollar.
[vis-á-vis, from French = in relation to, relative to, face-to-face, counterpart]
 Plaza Agreement G-5 (West Germany, France, Japan, US and UK) stabilized Japanese yen in the mid 1980s. (Plaza Accord, 1985) 
  When the currency of a large country is undervalued, another currency is overvalued. Accordingly, it creates a problem similar to that when a government defends a weak currency.
  In July 2005, China adopted a new policy, pegging Renminbi to a basket of currencies (USD, euro, yen and won), but it is not freely floating vis-à-vis other currencies.

As of June 2015, China's foreign exchange reserve surges to $3.99 trillion, but has since declined. Such intervention has resulted in a huge loss to China.

This is one reason for the US and EU to lower the interest rates.

Mundel's alternative view

 after 2020? Once RMB is freely traded, there would be four major currencies in the foreign exchange markets: RMB, yen, euro and dollar.